Midnight Commissions: The Story Behind Marbury v. Madison

Before leaving office in 1801, President John Adams signed commissions for new judges, and when the incoming Jefferson administration failed to deliver one, William Marbury petitioned for a writ of mandamus.

Writing for a unanimous Court, Chief Justice John Marshall held that Marbury deserved his commission but that the statute granting original jurisdiction exceeded Article III and was void.

By striking down part of the Judiciary Act of 1789, the Court asserted the power to invalidate acts of Congress that conflict with the Constitution, making the judiciary an equal constitutional actor..

Back to Blog