Unanimous Decisions That Endured
When all nine justices agree, the country usually listens. Marbury v. Madison, decided unanimously in 1803, established judicial review and made the Court a coequal branch. Brown v.
Board of Education in 1954, also unanimous, declared segregated schools unconstitutional and dismantled the legal regime of Plessy v. Ferguson. Cooper v. Aaron in 1958 unanimously reaffirmed the desegregation order against Arkansas resistance, and United States v.
Nixon in 1974 forced a president to surrender the Watergate tapes. This database catalogs each ruling with its vote breakdown, holding, and historical context, so readers can trace which consensus decisions still govern American life and which were later narrowed by divided courts..
Back to Blog